- This topic has 10 replies, 3 voices, and was last updated 1 month ago by
.
-
-
-
That’s a good list. It does get hard to narrow it down. I like “top 10” more then a list lol
Purdy has done way more than a young Caleb or Jayden in this league. So that’s two
Dak is arguable. I like Dak but….hes a Great numbers guy but need more winning and higher playoff seeds. But hes def been a victim of no D behind him. Dallas is gonna make noise this year
You left off hurts. And I would too but he’s in the convo.
i actually don’t love Stafford. 1) i don’t think he’s clutch. He was 1-8 or 0-7 on 3rd downs in NFCCG last year. I’ve thought that a long time actually. He can’t move. Hes not a great thrower on the run. Those are real deficiencies. Puka helps Stafford more than the other way around IMO. Dude is both wide open all the time and makes great contested catches. Lol
-
This reply was modified 1 month ago by
.
-
This reply was modified 1 month ago by
-
This reply was modified 1 month ago by
-
This reply was modified 1 month ago by
-
This reply was modified 1 month ago by
-
Physical talent alone. Regardless of D behind them or Supporting cast or resume or division or head coach.
Arm strength. Arm accuracy. Mobility. Long ball accuracy. Intermediate accuracy. Off platform throws. Toughness. Clutch gene.
cant measure smarts. Or audible ability. Just step back and throw, or scramble or take off list.
1. Allen
2. Herbert (I said that after his Rose Bowl victory)
only dude since 2018 that was physically more talented then Sam
If he ran over dudes like Allen he would be one. Hes actually faster. And he might have a bigger arm. Abs freak. And he gets to be best looking and chillest dude in league. Yeah I hate him 😂😉
3. Darnold
If he had a propensity to run more like Allen and Herbert he could be #1. But he doesn’t seem to love it like Allen does. And yes he would get hurt
4. Mahomes? Caleb??? Or Lamar??
Caleb’s accuracy worries me. Same with Lamar but he’s been better than Caleb.
I love Mahomes but he’s actually been terrible on the long ball the last few seasons. His WR core isn’t great nor is his RB room. So tough to say
hes def gotten older last few years
BTW Sam would have made this list before 2024 Vikings. And people would have called me crazy
-
I was on the fence with Hurts, but I think I would prefer Purdy over Hurts. Stafford was the last on my list along with Daniels tbh, big on stats but yes, is he clutch? He’s a gamer but does it result in cutch wins? Dunno. I’m not a fan of Dak, but I think if he was in those Super bowls as opposed to Purdy and Jimmy G they might very well have pulled one out. He has the physical tools. I agree with you, gulp, I think they make the nfc championship game at minimum. The Rams should rebound, the 9ers looked awesome, the Bears are coming on, the Seahawks won a clutch game w/out Darnold – so it’s a tough road. And the eagles are there too. The NFC def looks tougher to me than the afc this year
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.