I started this poll on an unbiased site called footballguys after some of you were flapping your gums on he was a hall of famer. Very few times is there a poll with over 100 votes, two options and one option gets zero votes since there usually is atleast one person that does a troll vote. Over 120 votes and not a single person thinks Palmer is a hall of famer, even some commented in the thread they thought I was making a troll post.
top of page
To see this working, head to your live site.
Edited: Mar 23, 2021
Poll is Carson Palmer a Hall Of Famer?
Poll is Carson Palmer a Hall Of Famer?
29 comments
Like
29 Comments
bottom of page
Yes. No brainer. Top 12 in several passing categories. Way ahead of other HOFs. His only knock is no rings, but it’s not his fault he played for shitty teams. Aikman would have zero rings if he played in Cleveland.
Andrew Luck in 6-7 Seasons has more TDs than aikman. Ouch.
List is crazy right.
How did Aikman only throw for 33k?
How the hell did Kerry Collins throw for over 40k yards?
No not quite ... the injury derailed any chance.
If you have 120 people answering such a post they all are either complete morons or hate Palmer for some reason. Probably a bunch of your Bruin butt buddies
I would say he is. I am not a huge NFL fan but the guy threw for a lot of yards. Took two dead franchises and made them competitive. Had some great stats and a long career. He doesn't measure up to his contemporaries Rivers, Brees and Brady so for that reason I could accept that he's not. I wonder how his career stats measure up to Eli Manning, who will be a very debatable but likely candidate.
While it’s not that important to Me. I think he is. We tend to put way too much emphasis on end of season one game performance. Example. There were people who last year debated whether clayton kershaw was h til the Dodgers won the series. That’s ludicrous. And I think there are a lot of parallels between the two
Absolutely. It’s not his fault he played on shit teams.
His career numbers place far above guys that are in the HOF.
Your Trojan obsession noted. Who cares?
He was a good player that was never the same after his injury.
Always represented USC well, good guy.
Letting the interception machine Aikman in because he was good at handing off a football makes the whole "hall" a joke. sc
This must be payback for pasadena's Aikman obsession.
I have not followed his statistics but I would use three criteria to determine if a player should make the Hall of Fame:
Statistics & Ratings
Years of Play
Championships