I'd always take my chances with 5 stars then have to coach up 2 and 3 star guys
McCay will probably go down as the best but he had the advantages of the 60s and 70s when you could stock pile 110 players.
To me Pete was the best. yeah, he stockpiled 5 star guys but he was the best motivator in college football. He did mess up that Texas NC game though, and Bush trying to laterial. I still recall laughing when you guys hired him since he was like 3rd or 4th choice. dang was I wrong.
I was surprised that Robinson's second tour of duty failed though, not sure what happenned there.