See for example 1. Oklahoma (at least two ineligible players played entire season and bowl game and no wins vacated - originally were but vacated wins were rescinded on appeal because COA rules that it was not a violation of NCAA rules for Oklahoma to fail to discover that Bomar and the OL were employed by its booster, so it decided penalties should be reduced, with no mention that OU also failed to discover that its booster who provided free cars to the OU coaching staff and to Adrian Peterson was paying money to Bomar and OL when they in fact did not work) 2. Ohio St (ineligible Troy Smith and no wins vacated) 3. Florida (At least EIGHTEEN players ineliglbie with Tank Black providing benefits including one getting a Mercedes Benz and no wins vacated and no penalties at all except public reprmiand) 4. Michigan (Charles Woodson took benefits and no wins vacated and no penalties at all).